Crumbl Pumpkin Cheesecake Cookie Review, Price & Calories 2026

Crumbl Pumpkin Cheesecake Cookie Price & Calories

Keep in mind that Crumbl’s prices and calorie counts can vary slightly by location and weekly menu rotation, so it’s always worth double-checking in the Crumbl app or at your local store before ordering.

My Review about it!

I bake a pumpkin pie every November that my family requests by name, so this cookie got the notebook treatment: plate, pen, and a slice of my own pie next to it for reference. That is either quality control or insecurity, and I have decided it is quality control.

It is $4.49 and served chilled, which is the first thing it gets right — pumpkin cheesecake should be cold, with the frosting firm. At 850 calories it sits with the cakes at the top of this week’s chart, so the notebook entry started with ‘share it’ underlined twice. I did not share it.

The first bite is graham first — buttery, a little salty — then the pumpkin cheesecake frosting, which is properly spiced rather than pumpkin-flavored candy. The streusel on top gives back the crunch the frosting takes away. Against my pie: the cookie is sweeter and richer, the pie is spicier and lighter, and they are genuinely different desserts wearing the same color.

Notebook conclusion, since this one gets one: the spice balance is the thing I would steal — warm without the raw cinnamon burn cheap pumpkin spice leaves behind. It will not replace pie at my table, but as a chilled, grab-and-go version of the same idea, it is the most grown-up cookie Crumbl put out this week.

What I liked

What I didn’t

Compared with the Cookies & Cream Tres Leches Cake: the tres leches is a chocolate cake drowned happily in milk sauce, soft enough to eat with a spoon, while this cookie stays firm, spiced and sliceable. The cake is the richer soak; the cheesecake cookie is the tidier dessert. Both want to be eaten cold, straight from the fridge.

Ingredients:

A chilled buttery graham cookie layered with pumpkin cheesecake frosting and graham cracker streusel topping — Crumbl’s official description.

Allergy Information:

Contains: Milk, Egg, Soy, Wheat; may contain Sesame, Tree Nuts, Peanut, Fish, Shellfish

Note: This information is not medical or physician advice, and it does not replace consulting a doctor or allergist about your specific condition. If you experience any allergic reaction after eating, seek medical attention immediately or call emergency services.

As with all Crumbl desserts, they are made in a shared kitchen environment, so cross-contact with other allergens including peanuts, tree nuts, and sesame is possible.

Gluten Free?

No. It contains both wheat and milk directly, so it isn’t suitable for gluten-free or dairy-free diets.

Nutrition Facts:

Here are the official nutrition facts for the Pumpkin Cheesecake Cookie:

Like this Cookie? Try Crumbl Cookies & Cream Tres Leches Cake — if you want the soaked-cake route, dark chocolate under whipped cream.

Pumpkin Cheesecake Cookie vs Cookies & Cream Tres Leches Cake: firm or soaked?

Other Top Reviews from Crumbl Cookies Official:

Pumpkin Cheesecake Cookie reviews are based on the highest number of upvotes — currently 4.42 from 59,868 ratings.

Tried this cookie? Download the Crumbl App to write a review!

FAQs