Crumbl Peanut Butter Cup Blondie Cookie Review, Price & Calories 2026

Crumbl Peanut Butter Cup Blondie Cookie Price & Calories

Keep in mind that Crumbl’s prices and calorie counts can vary slightly by location and weekly menu rotation, so it’s always worth double-checking in the Crumbl app or at your local store before ordering.

My Review about it!

The blondie lasted about four minutes after the school bags hit the floor. I had cut it into quarters on the kitchen island — one for each of us and one ‘for later’ that nobody believed in — and the first quarter disappeared before the milk was even poured. Warm from the box, it smelled like a peanut butter jar opened inside a bakery.

I picked it up on the school-run route and paid $4.49 for the single, which for a cookie this dense feels fair. It is the kind of thing you buy one of and share, not one per person — at 600 calories for the whole blondie, a quarter lands near 150 and still tastes like a full dessert.

The first bite is chopped peanut butter cup in every direction — not a swirl on top, actual pieces folded through a soft peanut butter base, with the milk chocolate drizzle going melty from the warmth. The edges have that blondie chew, the middle stays soft, and the peanut butter flavor is loud without turning salty.

We finished the whole thing standing up in the kitchen, which tells you most of it. The ‘for later’ quarter went last and slowest. It is rich in the way peanut butter desserts are rich — one more bite always sounds good and then suddenly you are done. A cold glass of milk is not optional with this one; it is part of the recipe.

What I liked

What I didn’t

Compared with the Dirt Cake Cookie: that one is a dark-chocolate maximalist — fudge frosting, cookie crumbs, a gummy worm on top — while the blondie runs on peanut butter warmth. Dirt Cake is louder; the blondie is richer. Chocolate people go Dirt Cake, peanut butter people do not even hesitate.

Ingredients:

A peanut butter cookie baked with chopped peanut butter cups, topped with drizzles of melty milk chocolate and peanut butter — Crumbl’s official description.

Allergy Information:

Contains: Milk, Egg, Soy, Wheat, Peanut; may contain Tree Nuts

Note: This information is not medical or physician advice, and it does not replace consulting a doctor or allergist about your specific condition. If you experience any allergic reaction after eating, seek medical attention immediately or call emergency services.

As with all Crumbl desserts, they are made in a shared kitchen environment, so cross-contact with other allergens including peanuts, tree nuts, and sesame is possible.

Gluten Free?

No. It contains both wheat and milk directly, so it isn’t suitable for gluten-free or dairy-free diets.

Nutrition Facts:

Here are the official nutrition facts for the Peanut Butter Cup Blondie Cookie:

Like this Cookie? Try Crumbl Dirt Cake Cookie — if you want the chocolate version of loaded, with fudge frosting and a gummy worm on top.

Peanut Butter Cup Blondie Cookie vs Dirt Cake Cookie: which loaded cookie wins?

Other Top Reviews from Crumbl Cookies Official:

Peanut Butter Cup Blondie Cookie reviews are based on the highest number of upvotes — currently 4.61 from 5,601 ratings.

Tried this cookie? Download the Crumbl App to write a review!

FAQs