Crumbl vs Insomnia Cookies: Prices, Size, Calories, Hours & Which Is Better
Crumbl vs Insomnia Cookies — The Honest Head-to-Head (2026)
Two cookie giants, two opposite philosophies. Crumbl sells a giant, weekly-rotating, frosting-loaded event in a pink box. Insomnia sells a warm, classic cookie delivered to your door at 2 in the morning. This comparison puts them side by side on price, size, calories, menu, hours, delivery and taste — with real numbers, and a clear winner in every round.
The verdict in 30 seconds
Choose Crumbl if you want the bigger, richer, more exciting cookie — new flavors every week, cakes and desserts alongside, and a box worth photographing. Choose Insomnia if you want warm cookies delivered late at night (until 1–3 AM), a smaller everyday price, and the classics done right, any day of the week — including Sunday, when every Crumbl is closed. Overall winner: Crumbl — the better cookie, the better value per dollar, and the box worth gifting. Insomnia stays champion of exactly one arena Crumbl does not contest: a warm cookie at 2 AM on a Sunday.
The Two Brands, Side by Side
Crumbl
- Founded: 2017, Logan, Utah (Jason McGowan and Sawyer Hemsley)
- Stores: 1,000+ across the US and Canada
- The idea: a weekly menu drop — six new or returning flavors every Monday, revealed Sunday night
- The product: very large, thick, frosting-and-topping-loaded cookies, plus cakes, desserts, minis and dirty sodas at participating stores
Insomnia Cookies
- Founded: 2003, in a University of Pennsylvania dorm room (Seth Berkowitz)
- Stores: 350+ bakeries across the US, Canada and the UK
- The idea: warm cookies, delivered — built for students and night owls from day one
- The product: classic bakery cookies in two sizes (Classic and Deluxe), cookie cakes, brownies, ice cream and cookie sandwiches
Head-to-Head: The Master Table
| Crumbl | Insomnia Cookies | |
|---|---|---|
| Menu model | Weekly rotation — 6 flavors + 2 staples (Milk Chocolate Chip, Pink Sugar) | Fixed menu — 10+ Classics and 6+ Deluxe always available, plus limited-time drops |
| Single cookie | $4.49 (Large) | $3.50–$4.25 (Classic) · $5.50–$7.00 (Deluxe) |
| 6-pack | $23.29 | About $17.50–$22.25 by city |
| 12-pack | $43.99 | About $30.75–$41.50 by city |
| Cookie size | Large ≈ serves 2; Mini line for small bites | Classic ≈ a normal bakery cookie; Deluxe is the big one |
| Calories | Large 530–950 · Mini 120–310 | Classic roughly 300–400 · Deluxe roughly 540–650 |
| Hours | Mon–Sat (typically 8 AM–10 PM); closed Sundays | 7 days; until 1 AM Sun–Wed, 3 AM Thu–Sat at most bakeries |
| Delivery | Pickup-first; delivery via apps at many stores | Delivery is the brand — own drivers + apps, late into the night |
| Ice cream | Not a core offer | Core offer — scoops, pints, cookie’wiches, cookies in ice cream |
| Extras | Dirty sodas, cakes, catering, gift cards | Cookie cakes, brownies, brookies, catering boxes |
| Dietary | No standing vegan or gluten-free cookie line | Vegan and gluten-free options on the Classic menu |
| Best for | The weekly treat, parties, gifting, flavor hunters | Late-night cravings, dorms, offices, everyday cookie runs |
Crumbl prices are our standard checked prices (November 2026; they vary a little by store — see the full breakdown on our Crumbl prices page). Insomnia prices are sampled from current US menus in November 2026 and vary by city; calorie figures for Insomnia are approximate from its published nutrition information. Crumbl calories are verified from Crumbl’s own store listings and nutrition chart.
Round 1 — The Menu: Rotation vs Reliability
Crumbl turns its menu into an event. Every Sunday night the new week is revealed, every Monday six flavors land — some brand-new, some returning favorites — next to the always-on Milk Chocolate Chip and Pink Sugar. The full current lineup lives on our Crumbl flavors page, and the week ahead is previewed on the next week page. The catch: when a flavor’s week ends, it is gone — sometimes for a year.
Insomnia is the opposite promise: your favorite is simply there. Chocolate Chunk, Snickerdoodle, Double Chocolate Chunk, Peanut Butter Chip, M&M’S, Oatmeal Raisin and a vegan gluten-free chocolate chip are on the board every day, with bigger Deluxe versions (S’mores, Salted Caramel, Triple Chocolate, Confetti, Peanut Butter Cup) above them. Limited flavors appear, but the core never rotates away.
Winner: Crumbl — a menu that reinvents itself every single week, adds cakes and desserts alongside the cookies, and turns Monday into an event beats a board that never changes. Insomnia’s reliability is real, but a fixed menu is a smaller menu in every way that counts: fewer flavors, fewer formats, nothing new to come back for.
Round 2 — Size and Calories: The Heavyweight vs The Classic
A Crumbl Large is a genuinely big cookie — most people split one or save half. This week’s verified lineup runs from 530 calories (Oatmeal Creme Pie) to 950 (Double Fudge Brownie), with Minis at 120–310 for a saner portion. The full chart, updated weekly, is on our Crumbl nutrition page.
An Insomnia Classic is a normal-sized bakery cookie — roughly 300–400 calories — and a Deluxe lands around 540–650, about where a Crumbl Mini-to-Large middle ground sits. Nobody buys either brand for diet food, but the honest difference is portion: Insomnia sells you a cookie; Crumbl sells you a dessert.
Winner: Crumbl for size and shareability. Portion control, though, belongs to Insomnia’s Classics and Crumbl’s own Minis.
Round 3 — Price and Value
Per cookie, Insomnia’s Classic ($3.50–$4.25) undercuts a Crumbl single ($4.49) — but the Crumbl cookie is far bigger, so per bite the gap mostly disappears. Insomnia’s Deluxe ($5.50–$7.00) is the closest thing to a Crumbl Large in size, and there Crumbl is actually cheaper. Packs tell the same story: Insomnia’s 12-pack (about $31–$42 by city) beats Crumbl’s $43.99 on sticker price, with smaller cookies inside.
Where Crumbl quietly wins: premium flavors (cakes, skillet cookies) add a $0.99 upcharge, clearly marked, and Mini packs (from $9.99 for 3) give a budget route Insomnia’s menu does not really have. Where Insomnia wins: no upcharges, and late-night delivery fees are its home turf rather than an app markup.
Winner: Crumbl — judged on cookie per dollar, it is not close. Crumbl’s $4.49 Large outweighs Insomnia’s similarly-sized Deluxe at $5.50–$7.00, Mini packs open a $9.99 route Insomnia has no answer to, and the Crumbl 12-Pack delivers twelve desserts, not twelve snacks. Insomnia’s Classic is the cheaper single cookie — but you pay less because you get less.
Round 4 — Hours: Sunday and 2 AM Decide It
This is the starkest difference in the whole comparison. Crumbl is closed every Sunday — no exceptions — and most stores close around 10 PM the rest of the week (check yours on our Crumbl hours page). Insomnia opens seven days, and its whole identity is the late shift: most bakeries deliver until 1 AM Sunday–Wednesday and 3 AM Thursday–Saturday.
Sunday birthday? Insomnia. Midnight study session? Insomnia. Saturday afternoon pink box run? Crumbl, all day.
Winner: Insomnia — and it is the biggest single win in this article.
Round 5 — Delivery and Ordering
Insomnia was delivering warm cookies before food-delivery apps existed, and it shows: its own drivers, delivery zones built around each bakery, and orders until the small hours. Crumbl is a pickup-first brand — its app handles ordering ahead beautifully, and delivery runs through third-party apps at many stores (details on our Crumbl delivery guide) — but a warm-at-2-AM cookie is simply not its game.
Winner: Insomnia
Round 6 — Beyond the Cookie: Ice Cream, Drinks, Cakes
Insomnia’s second menu is ice cream: scoops on warm cookies, cookie’wich sandwiches, pints, and its “Cookies IN Ice Cream” — none of which Crumbl answers. It also bakes cookie cakes and brownies year-round.
Crumbl’s second menu is everything else: rotating full-size cakes and chilled desserts most weeks, Dirty Sodas at participating stores (our 48-drink guide), and a proper catering program for events. For a party table, Crumbl’s variety is deeper; for a dessert-with-ice-cream, Insomnia’s is purpose-built.
Winner: Tie — pick by what sits next to the cookie at your table.
Round 7 — Dietary Options and Allergen Transparency
Insomnia keeps vegan and gluten-free options on its standing Classic menu — a real, permanent route for guests who need one. Crumbl has no standing vegan or gluten-free cookie line, so those guests rely on whatever the week brings (usually nothing).
On transparency, both publish nutrition and allergen information; Crumbl’s week-by-week charts are the ones we maintain on our Crumbl allergens page. Always check the current week’s chart — rotating flavors mean rotating allergens.
Winner: Insomnia for the standing dietary options.
Round 8 — Gifting, Parties and the Wow Factor
A Crumbl pink box is a gift before it is opened — the weekly lineup, the big frostings and the sheer size make it the box people photograph. Add a Crumbl gift card and it is a complete present, and our Thanksgiving guide shows how the boxes anchor a holiday dessert table. Insomnia gifting is more practical: cookie cakes with messages, big dozens that travel to offices and dorms, and delivery that lands exactly when the party runs late.
Winner: Crumbl for the gift moment; Insomnia for feeding a crowd after hours.
The Scorecard
| Round | Winner |
|---|---|
| Menu | Crumbl |
| Size and calories | Crumbl |
| Price and value | Crumbl |
| Hours | Insomnia |
| Delivery | Insomnia |
| Extras (ice cream vs cakes and sodas) | Tie |
| Dietary options | Insomnia |
| Gifting and wow factor | Crumbl |
Final: Crumbl 4 rounds · Insomnia 3 rounds · 1 tie — and the rounds matter more than the count.
The final verdict: Crumbl wins this comparison. It takes the menu, the size, the value and the gift box — the four rounds that are actually about the cookie. Insomnia’s wins are real, but they are about the clock, not the cookie: it is open on Sundays, it delivers at 2 AM, and it keeps a vegan and gluten-free option standing. Judge a cookie brand by the cookie first — and by that measure, this one is Crumbl’s.
So Which One Should You Choose?
- It is after 10 PM, or any time Sunday: Insomnia — Crumbl is closed.
- You want this week’s most talked-about flavor: Crumbl — check the next week menu so you do not miss the drop.
- You are feeding a study group at midnight: Insomnia, delivered warm.
- You are bringing dessert to impress: Crumbl 12-Pack, sliced into wedges.
- You need vegan or gluten-free: Insomnia’s standing options.
- You want ice cream with it: Insomnia — or a Crumbl store with Dirty Sodas nearby.
- You just want a normal cookie, today: Insomnia Classic. The craving will not wait for Monday’s drop.
Crumbl vs Insomnia Cookies — FAQs
Is Crumbl or Insomnia cheaper?
Per cookie, Insomnia’s Classic ($3.50–$4.25) is cheaper than a Crumbl single ($4.49) — but Crumbl’s cookie is much larger. Against Insomnia’s Deluxe ($5.50–$7.00), which is the comparable size, Crumbl is cheaper. Packs: Insomnia’s 12-pack runs about $31–$42 by city versus Crumbl’s $43.99 for twelve much bigger cookies.
Which cookies are bigger, Crumbl or Insomnia?
Crumbl, and it is not close. A Crumbl Large is a shareable dessert (530–950 calories across this week’s menu); an Insomnia Classic is a standard bakery cookie (roughly 300–400 calories), and its Deluxe (roughly 540–650) sits between a Crumbl Mini and a Large.
Is Insomnia Cookies open on Sunday?
Yes — Insomnia is open seven days a week, usually until 1 AM or later. Crumbl is closed every Sunday.
What time does Insomnia Cookies close?
At most bakeries, 1 AM Sunday–Wednesday and 3 AM Thursday–Saturday, for both the bakery and delivery. Crumbl stores typically close around 10 PM and are closed Sundays.
Does Insomnia deliver later than Crumbl?
Yes. Delivery is Insomnia’s founding idea — warm cookies by its own drivers until 1–3 AM. Crumbl delivery runs through ordering apps at many stores and follows store hours.
Which has better flavors?
For new and elaborate flavors, Crumbl — six fresh ones every week, frostings, fillings and cakes. For the classic bakery flavors done consistently, Insomnia — its Chocolate Chunk and Snickerdoodle never leave the menu.
Does Insomnia have vegan or gluten-free cookies?
Yes — vegan and gluten-free options sit on its standing Classic menu. Crumbl has no standing vegan or gluten-free line, so options depend on the weekly menu.
How many stores does each have?
Crumbl has 1,000+ stores across the US and Canada. Insomnia has 350+ bakeries across the US, Canada and the UK. Both are still opening new locations through 2026.
More Crumbl Guides
Sources: Crumbl’s official site and store listings (crumblcookies.com); Insomnia Cookies’ official site (insomniacookies.com) and current US menu listings sampled November 2026. Insomnia prices and calories vary by city and are shown as ranges. Unofficial fan guide; not affiliated with Crumbl or Insomnia Cookies.
