Ice Cream Cake Sandwich Cookie
The Crumbl Ice Cream Cake Sandwich Cookie features two soft sugar cookies sandwiched around pink vanilla buttercream. It is topped with dollops of ice cream-inspired buttercream and finished with a colorful pinch of rainbow sprinkles.
4.47 avg rating | 1,234 reviews
Crumbl Ice Cream Cake Sandwich Cookie Price & Calories
Large Cookie
$4.99 – 950 Cal
Mini Cookie
$3.33– 220 Cal
Explore: Complete Crumbl Cookies menu
My Review about it!
I will be straight with you. I wanted to love this one.
It arrives looking like a tiny birthday cake. Two pale sugar cookies, a thick layer of pink vanilla buttercream pressed between them, more buttercream piped on top in soft dollops, and a scatter of rainbow sprinkles. It is the prettiest thing on the board this week. My first reaction was that Crumbl finally made a cookie that photographs itself.
Then I ate it.
The sugar cookie is soft and buttery, and honestly it is one of the better sugar bases Crumbl has done. It is not as aggressively sweet as their usual pink sugar cookie. That part I liked. The problem is everything stacked around it. The pink buttercream in the middle is thick and very sweet, and the dollops on top pile more of the same sweetness on. By the third bite the flavor stops evolving. It is vanilla, then sugar, then vanilla again.
The ice cream part is the piece that let me down. The frosting has that cool creamy texture that does remind you of a soft serve cake from the grocery store freezer. But the flavor never follows. There is no cold cream tang, no crunchy chocolate layer, nothing that says ice cream cake. It reads as a very sweet sugar cookie in a costume. A pinch of salt in the frosting would have fixed most of it.
The sprinkles do nothing for taste. They do everything for the vibe. I understand why they are there.
Would I order it again? In mini form, yes. At 950 calories for the full size, the frosting to cookie ratio is a lot to get through alone. The mini gives you the same look and the same flavor without the sugar headache at the end.
My rating: 7.5 out of 10. Gorgeous, nostalgic, and fun to bring to a party. Just do not expect it to taste like ice cream cake.
Ingredients:
A symphony of flour, sugar, butter, eggs, and chocolate, come together for our deliciously large gourmet desserts.
Allergy Information:
Contains: Milk, Eggs, Wheat, Soy
Desserts are handcrafted on-site in a shared preparation area. As a result, all products may contain or be exposed to allergens such as peanuts, tree nuts, milk, eggs, wheat, soy, and sesame.
Gluten Free?
No. It contains both wheat and milk directly, so it isn’t suitable for gluten-free or dairy-free diets.
Nutrition Facts:
Here are nutritional facts for Ice Cream Cake Sandwich Cookie
|
Cookie |
Calories |
Total Fat |
Saturated Fat |
Trans Fat |
Cholesterol |
Sodium |
Carbs |
Fiber |
Total Sugars |
Protein |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Large |
950 kcal |
35 g |
23 g |
0 g |
104 mg |
317 mg |
104 g |
0 g |
58 g |
12 g |
|
Mini |
360 kcal |
10 g |
7 g |
0 g |
29 mg |
96 mg |
31 g |
0 g |
17 g |
2 g |
Like this Cookie? Try Crumbl White Drop Cookie or Crumbl Berry Limeade Cookie
Top Reviews:
Ice Cream Cake Sandwich Cookie reviews are based on the highest number of upvote.
I really think this is a menu item worth keeping it’s that good and I really love cake so putting a ice cream cake is genius and is absolutely amazing
— Johnathan H.
if ice
— yeshian i.
This thing looks like a 1980s mall food court fever dream rendered in frosting — pink, excessive, cheerful, and completely unconcerned with subtlety. The two sugar cookies are soft, buttery, and restrained…
— Colin B.
Tried this cookie? Download the Crumbl App to write a review!
FAQs
READY FOR YOUR WEEKLY BOX?
Don’t miss out Crumbl this week’s limited flavors. They are waiting for you!
